Background: I am a middle and high school math
teacher at Connections Learning, which is an online education program for
students. In a virtual environment, I am unable
to offer direct instruction and be a part of my students learning process each
day. Our curriculum is set up so that students work through lessons on their
own, and learn the material through various teachlets, tutorials, videos and
examples. Students are also given the online textbook to use for learning and
completing practice problems.
Because students don’t work with their
teacher every day, Connections Learning offers a free online tutoring service to
its students. This
service is called LiveTutor, and it consists of a virtual room staffed with
teachers who are available throughout the day for students to access when they
have questions. This is a great
opportunity for students to interact with a live teacher and get help.
Problem of Practice: The problem that I researched this
semester is that students do not use LiveTutor to get help when they have
questions.
I used
Standford’s Design process, which includes five different modes, in order to learn
why this problem is occurring, and to come up with solutions to solve this
problem.
Empathize Mode: I used three different methods in
order to empathize with my students to better understand why they are not using
this awesome resource:
1) Interview – I spoke with 3 of my students over
the phone and asked them questions about their daily math routine and their
familiarity and experience using LiveTutor
2) Survey – I emailed 15 students and asked them
to complete a short survey to learn about their experiences with LiveTutor and
their daily math routine
3) Immersion – I simulated my students condition
by working through a math lesson from start to finish, in order to experience
what my students go through each day in order to complete their math work
Results:
I learned a
few things by empathizing with my students in each of these ways. The survey
results informed me that only 50% of students know what LiveTutor is. Please
see Appendix A to view the results from my survey.
The survey
results, along with the interviews I completed, also informed me that students
are not spending enough time on their math lessons each day. 60% of the
students I surveyed complete math in 30 minutes or less, and the students I
interviewed shared with me that they spend an average of 15 minutes on math
each day. I learned through my interviews that some students are just clicking
through a lesson in order to complete it instead of taking the time to complete
all parts of the lesson as intended in order to learn the material.
I learned through
immersion that students should be spending an average of 45 minutes to an hour
on math each day. When I simulated my student’s condition and completed a
lesson from start to finish, it took me 35 minutes. This did not include
spending any time using extra resources such as LiveTutor to get help, and
also, since I already know the material, I was likely able to work through the
lesson and complete practice problems at a faster pace than a student who is learning
the content for the first time.
Empathizing
with my students provided me with great insight as to why my problem is occurring.
This allowed me to determine which direction to pursue to solve this problem.
Define Mode: After empathizing with my students, and
completing the 5 Whys? Root-Cause Analysis
(see Appendix B), I was able to identify the root causes of why my problem
is occurring. This allowed me to define my problem from my point of view, which
provided focus and my unique vision for moving forward with my project.
Problem Statement:
My online students don’t use LiveTutor, a free tutoring
service that is offered to them, to get help throughout the day. There are two root causes for why this problem is occurring.
The first issue is that many of my students do not know that this service is
available to them to use. In order to address this issue, I am going to share
this information with students in a way that will ensure that this information is
not overlooked.
The second issue is that students who are familiar
with LiveTutor and would benefit from this service are not spending enough time
on math each day. Students have a tendency to rush through their lessons in
order to get them done, as opposed to slowing down to learn the material and
get help. I plan to help students see the benefit of taking their time to work
through a lesson, completing practice problems and seeking help before moving
on to the assessment at the end of the lesson. Using LiveTutor should be a part
of student’s daily routine to get their questions answered, and I believe that
students will use LiveTutor more often if they can experience how beneficial it
is to their understanding and being successful.
Ideate Mode: I used various brainstorming and incubation
techniques to generate ideas for possible solutions to my problem:
1)
I
brainstormed with one of my colleagues via web conference, and we completed the
Random Words technique that was described in Chapter 5 of “Cracking Creativity”
by Michael Michalko. Please see Appendix C to view our notes from this
brainstorming session.
2)
I kept an
incubation journal. Please see Appendix D.
3)
“Work –
Incubate – Revisit” Module 4 Lab Activity. Please see Appendix E.
4)
Module 3
Group Discussion Forum – idea shared with me from a classmate
Each of these activities led me to two possible solutions that I pursued
in the prototype mode.
Prototype Mode: I created two prototypes that will help me solve my
problem of practice:
1)
VIDEO – This prototype was designed to address one of the root causes of my
problem, which is that students do not know about this resource. I created an 8
minute video tutorial that explains what LiveTutor is and how to use it. I will
email this video to my students in hopes that they will learn about this
awesome resource so that they can use it to get help.
2)
ASSIGNMENT – This prototype addresses
the second root cause of my problem, which is that students have a tendency to
rush through their lessons, and don’t take extra time to practice or get help
when they need it. I created an assignment that will require students to slow
down, complete an entire lesson from start to finish as it is intended instead
of skipping through parts just to finish, and it also requires students to
attend LiveTutor and get help. My hope is that when students complete a lesson
this way, they will experience the benefits of slowing down and using
LiveTutor. You may click here to view the assignment prototype that I created. You may also
click here to view the lesson that this assignment is linked to.
Test Mode: I chose 3 different methods to test my prototypes.
1)
First, I
tested my prototype with the five students I surveyed in the empathize mode who
did not know about LiveTutor. I emailed my video prototype to these students,
and asked them to complete a survey after watching the video to learn if they
now know what LiveTutor is. Please view Appendix F to see the survey questions.
Only one of the five students I contacted responded.
This showed me that this prototype was not
productive, since only one student watched the video and completed the survey.
2)
Next, I shared
my prototypes with my sister, who recently graduated from college and can
identify with the role of a student. She is also someone who will give me
honest feedback from the perspective of someone who isn’t directly involved
with my issue.
She let me know that the video I created is too
long, and shared with me some tips for shortening it so that students will be
more likely to watch it. She also suggested created a quick and easy assignment
to go with the video, asking students to email me sharing one thing that they
learned from the video.
We also reviewed the assignment I created, and she
thinks that since students are already prone to rush through lessons, adding
more work isn’t the best idea. I should modify and simplify the assignment by
asking students to identify one topic from the lesson they were confused about,
requiring them to go to LiveTutor to get help on this topic, and then submitting
to me what they learned in LiveTutor to help. I should also let students know
that I can check to see when they attend LiveTutor so that they do not make it
up and pretend that they went to get help.
3)
Lastly, I
met with a colleague, who experiences this same issue with her students. She
gave me valuable feedback on the assignment that I created, and you may view
the notes that I took on her feedback in Appendix G.
The feedback that I received from my students, my colleague and my sister
gave me new ideas about how to redesign my prototypes so that they are more
effective in solving my problem:
Video Redesign: I will recreate my video to be around 2 minutes long,
and I will email it to students to watch and ask them to respond with one thing
they learned from the video.
Assignment Redesign: I will ask students to complete the practice problems
from the textbook and submit their work to me, identifying which problems they
answered correctly and incorrectly by checking their answers in the back of the
textbook. This will not add extra work for students, since this is already part
of the lesson. I will then ask students to go to the LiveTutor room to get help
on the problems they missed, and submit to me when they went and what they
learned. Lastly, I will have students tell me how long the lesson took them
from start to finish, including going to LiveTutor, instead of documenting each
step of the way.
Conclusion: I learned that each mode of the
design process is necessary in order create solutions that successfully solve
problems. If any phase is not included in the process, you will miss out on key
elements that are needed to inform your decisions along the way. I also learned
that each phase will likely need to be completed more than once, and they do
not necessarily need to be completed in this order when designing. For example,
after working through one full cycle of Standford’s Design process, I will
recreate my prototypes and test them again in an effort to create the best
possible solutions to my problem.
I never considered myself to be a designer before this
course. However, after learning about Standford’s Design process and completing
one full cycle, I realize that anyone, including myself, can be a designer. Now
that I have a process to follow, and have skills and tools to help me throughout
the process, I can apply what I have learned in this course when designing in
my career and personal life in the future.
Please click here
to view the Appendix for this report.